Asking for it
by digby
Ok, this is very creepy. It's about a document from Bill Gothard's home schooling cult that tells people like the Duggars how to deal with sexual abuse:
The document describes a situation in which social workers visited a home and informed the parents that their oldest son had sexually abused younger members of his family.
According to the document, the boy repented for what he had done and was later asked to answer a list of questions in writing to shed more insight on what happened.
The questions included asking what factors had contributed to his sin, what could have been done to prevent it, and what factors “in the home contributed to immodesty and temptation.”
“The information he gives is so helpful that every parent should read it and diligently apply the lessons that this family learned the hard way,” the document states.
The most striking part of the document comes when the boy seems to blame his actions on the lack of “modesty” in his home, especially when it came to his young sisters.
The boy wrote that modesty was a “factor” in his actions because it “was not at the level is should have been in my family.”
“It was not uncommon for my younger sibling to come out of their baths naked or with a towel,” he wrote.
He also said his younger sisters acted inappropriately when they wore dresses, saying they “did not behave in them as they should.”
He then said his sisters didn’t realize what they were doing to him because they didn’t realize their “own nakedness,” and it wasn’t taught properly to them. He seems to blame this on his mother, who he says didn’t see the human body as a big deal because she is a nurse.
The boy said he spoke with his mother who had “no idea” how “visual” men are sexually compared to women. He said changes have since been made in his home.
“This was not a major reason for the offending, but it allowed my little sister to be open to what I made her do,” he wrote.
He then wrote, “A different lifestyle, with more modesty, might have prevented what happened.”
The document then provides guidelines as to how to prevent this type of situation. These include “[insisting] on modesty at all times” and “[not allowing] boys to change diapers.”
There was this as well:
The document suggests that a victim of sexual abuse is damaging themselves by being “bitter” about what happened.
It also seems to imply the victim should be feeling guilt about what happened. The reasons for this guilt may be “disobedience” or “not reporting it,” it states.
In addition, the document reference there is a potential for “moral vaccination.”
That term is described in an article by Recovering Grace:
Moral vaccination” seems to reference a concept Gothard shared in seminars and conferences in the 1980s, when he told the story of a woman who struggled with unwanted sexual thoughts and eventually was raped. In the anecdote, Gothard described the rape and the woman’s subsequent aversion to sexuality as inoculation against lust.
I think we can all agree that this throwback attitude should have been left in the caves. But then you stop to think about it and see that there are many people, not just the Duggar Quiverful types for whom this attitude still subconsciously informs their views about women and assault. The right sees sexual assault as a false narrative in which women are pretending to be victims when they were actually active participants in the act in one way or another. (Those little girls who were "immodest" in their dresses for instance.) And if women are assaulted they likely put themselves into a situation they shouldn't have been in in the first place and must take some responsibility for what happened to them.
That's Bill Gothard's gothic patriarchal culture. It's also our culture.
Update: Because he cares about the victims, this Republican politician wants the chief of police fired for releasing Josh Duggar's arrest report. Uh huh.
Update II: That Buzzfeed story I linked at the beginning should have included some acknowledgement to Kathryn Joyce for her book Quiverfull: Inside the Christian Patriarchy Movement
and Sarah Posner who has written reams about Gothard as well. You really should read up on this if you haven't.
.