Americans like their privacy after all
At least according to this poll:
Fifty-nine percent of the survey's respondents said the programs that collect phone and Internet communications as a way to prevent terrorism collect too much information about Americans, while only 20 percent said the government strikes the right balance in deciding what data to collect. Six percent said the government doesn't go far enough in collecting that information.
Many Americans aren't even convinced that the surveillance programs do much to fight terrorism. A combined 43 percent said the phone and Internet data collection efforts are very likely (13 percent) or somewhat likely (30 percent) to have prevented a terrorist attack. But 47 percent said they were somewhat unlikely (23 percent) or very unlikely (24 percent) to have done so.
The poll was conducted after The Washington Post reported that most of the Internet communications intercepted and stored by the National Security Agency came from accounts belonging to ordinary citizens, including many Americans, who were not the intended targets of the surveillance. The Post report also found that the NSA's online surveillance had led directly to the capture of at least two terrorism suspects.
Forty-one percent of Americans in the new survey said the government is likely to have recorded their own emails or telephone calls. Only 18 percent said their communications haven't been recorded, while another 42 percent weren't sure.
Moreover, 57 percent think data collection programs that sweep in Americans' phone and Internet data are "an unnecessary intrusion into Americans' lives," while only 23 percent think those efforts are "justified as a way to combat terrorism."
Whether or not their votes would be affected by this belief is another story. Let's just say I doubt it:
The "goes too far" view was shared by 66 percent of Republicans, 63 percent of independents and a 48 percent plurality of Democrats.
I'm pretty sure we can flip the Republicans and Democrats depending on who's president. Recall this:
Opinion about the legality of Bush's [wiretapping] actions varies widely by political affiliation. Seventy-seven percent of Democrats believe Bush broke the law, compared with 58% of independents and 16% of Republicans.
Similarly, 80% of liberals believe Bush broke the law, compared with 55% of moderates and just 26% of conservatives.
It's not exactly the same question but its close enough to illustrate the point.